Millard Fillmore Leaf Oval Office:
1/4 = $460
2/4 = $460
4/4 = $475
Millard Fillmore 1600 Penn:
1/1 = $700
MILLARD FILLMORE 1/1 CUT AUTOGRAPH 1600 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE 13TH PRESIDENT | eBay
And it's wise to keep in mind that not only did the 1600 Penn bring more, there was another cut and 4 other cards in that box. Oval Office only had that 1 cut that brought a lot less.
Oval Office cards won't always bring less, but there are several examples of them bringing a lot less.