Originally Posted by cromartie3145
He without question deserves it. What else could I have possibly done to make it right with him?
I gave him essentially a free card and money. I don't know what else I could have done.
You screwed up on your end of the deal by "forgetting" to ship. That warrants a negative feedback. What did the buyer do wrong in this deal? You left him a negative, because he left you one.
I think you did well on correcting your mistake
, but feedback is to warn other potential traders about you, and forgetting to ship an item is something that people should be warned about.