It's always a gamble when you request a redemption replacement. I think in almost all instances you are just better off waiting for the card. Especially since Hosmer has autos in current products. Topps uses both eBay & beckett to asses values on cards for replacements (those were their words).
Edit: Here are there direct words from the national when asked about value...
https://twitter.com/sportscardnews/s...37361097015296
https://twitter.com/sportscardnews/s...38172514476032
https://twitter.com/sportscardnews/s...38291200700416