I contacted Topps on Saturday, and they suggested I mail them back to the Duryea, PA address, with a letter explaining my situation.
So, that's what I did. Here's to hoping the USPS doesn't lose the shipment, and here's to hoping Topps gets it right the next go around.
Currently hosting: 2014 Bowman Inception Baseball 5-Case 200-Slot Hit Draft w/ $22.50 Buy-In! Now accepting backups!