I would say Rose or Jackson, but just to be different I'll go with Doc Gooden. He really helped turn the Mets around and win them a championship. He has a .631 win percentage, and was a strikeout leader a couple of times.
Lifelong Mets, Jets, and Nets fan.
No longer shipping internationally.
My SportsCardAlbum: http://sportscardalbum.com/u/hotbox