Originally Posted by seancoyle
He's having a great year no doubt, but what does what they did in their careers have anything to do with the Cy young award this year?
It technically doesn't but at least show me a guy who has proven himself. Cueto and Dickey are flukes for all we know. Verlander isn't having the best year but people are still considering for AL Cy Young and it can't be because he's out pitching everyone. Prior seasons really have nothing to do with this season, all I'm saying is someone who has been a winner before deserves a little more respect than some fluke stories.