Both are incredible cards, but I would take the Exquisite Retro Rookie any day of the week. Just an incredible card. Other than a MJ Auto Logoman I believe it's the best looking MJ card.
My Collection: http://s314.photobucket.com/albums/ll436/ultimate_deron/
CURRENTLY BUYING: Victor Oladipo, Klay Thompson, and D'Angelo Russell (High End Only)