wow......go kick sherlock holmes in the nuts and tell him he's fired. your investigative skills far surpass his knowledge.
on a more serious note. try contacting paypal again and present them with all of this information. ask to speak with a manager or something. they may be able to progress it along faster. that definitely is your card. what a scumbag d*ckhead move by that guy. hope you get your card back..............then again, there's always plan b. make a trip up north and break his legs for real then take the card back? just sayin.....
Carmelo Anthony collector........
Looking for Melo autographs and nice patches.