I pulled open a few boxes of 2010-11 Black box and pulled two Cedric Maxwell(fail) and also noticed that both Maxwell had foil peeling on the left edge. I sent both of them in separately with the wrapper they came in after I opened a ticket on panini. I think they took about a month to respond. They didn't honor mine just because it had been over a year since the product came out. But for yours, I am sure they will be able to replace such a thing. You'll just have to wait a while for them to respond. If they can't replace, my understanding is that they will bubble mail the original back to you, as they did for me.
KOBE, MCGRADY, DWIGHT