Update.
No mice in any glue traps (they've been down there since the first night I caught mice)
The regular traps the peanut butter was missing. But I still had traps just laying around with no bait.
My wife found we caught one.
I haven't been in that part of the basement for maybe a day
So within the past 24 hours, I caught one by the tail
Not sure how he got caught like this
