The redemptions for those rookies were suppose to be Non Autos. It seems like they kept the card with the writing on the back as auto'd None of the redemptions of those rookies come auto'd. What you have is an uncorrected error.
Let me know what your Lawyer says about it. They redemptions were never for Auto'd Xrc. So im wondering why you expect an auto?
Wtf mailday from panini redemptions..