Just took the plunge and picked up another PP #1 from amazon. Risky without seeing the scans like I would on eBay but I couldn't let it get away. Plus luck has been on my side. So far the two I purchased from amazon came back 9.8 and 9.6
I turned my fuel rewards from the gas station into $50 amazon gift card today. Then I came home searched amazon and found one for $199, so really it only cost $149, which is the price a 9.2 sold for this week. Hopefully the new/nm they had posted isn't too far off.