Ok I think I found a way to help prove that this is the 2005 Bowman Chrome A-Rod Throwback Autographs 94A-AR card and I don't know why I didn't think of this before.
You can take the serial number off the BGS case and look it up online on the Beckett website and it shows that this is that card.
Card Serial Number: 0004133288
Set Name : 2005 Bowman Chrome A-Rod Throwback Autographs
Player Name : A.Rodriguez 1994 SF/1
Date Graded : Tuesday, February 28, 2006
Centering Grade : 9.5
Corner Grade : 9.5
Edges Grade : 9.5
Surfaces Grade : 8.5
Autograph Grade : Not Available
Final Grade : 9.0