You really can't lose with either guy. Both Reed and Polamalu have been often injured in the last few years. The difference is that Reed has been able to play through the injuries more than Polamalu. You must understand that although these guys both play safety, free safety and strong safety are just different. Reed is no doubt the best ballhawk at the safety position ever, plus he can take an interception or missed field goal attempt all the way back for a touchdown. Polamalu is as physical and smart as any guy to ever play the position, yet he can make a play on the ball. It is a close call, but give me the more physical guy; give me Polamalu. The sad part is that with the new rules, I don't think there will be any room for a new Troy Polamalu in the near-future.
Last edited by starfox; 05-08-2013 at 10:34 PM.