Ok, good news for me. I escalated my issue and they agreed that they mis-valued the Brodeur EoE. Instead of giving me $150 each, they will value them at $225 each based on recent sale of other similar cards. They also agreed to take back the non-cup cards to compensate for the mistake, but warned this was a one-off.
So i am glad to see they agreed with my assessment and that of many of you. Now, we will have to wait and see what else i will get in return...