NL CY YOUNG
 

Who should it be? I personally think Dickey

Aroldis Chapman?

Dickey.......

As i made a thread before on this it will be:
Johnny Cueto or Aroldis Chapman. People thinking Dickey are waaayyyy off. Numbers arent close to Cueto

Why not Johnny Cueto ? It's probably RA Dickey's to lose right now but I think Cueto would be my choice.

[QUOTE=BAMBAM;3166573]Why not Johnny Cueto ? It's probably RA Dickey's to lose right now but I think Cueto would be my choice.[/QUOTE]

Should be Cuetos. Has better numbers and leading his team into playoffs. Aroldis Chapman is most dominant pitcher we have seen in years.

[QUOTE=cruiserdaddy7;3166582]Should be Cuetos. Has better numbers and leading his team into playoffs. Aroldis Chapman is most dominant pitcher we have seen in years.[/QUOTE]

Chapman is ridiculous this year BUT I don't like seeing modern day closers getting the Cy. I'd give it to a starter who dominates over a closer who dominates every time.

[QUOTE=cruiserdaddy7;3166582] Aroldis Chapman is most dominant pitcher we have seen in years.[/QUOTE]

if he was that dominant his era wouldn't be around a 1.40 and he wouldn't have any blown saves

Cueto should be the clear favorite right now...although I'd love to see Jordan Zimmermann challenge him over the next month.

Cueto definetly will win this year. His numbers are just too good not to!

Chapman is incredible but I can't see a closer winning it unless they have a record breaking or some crazy season like 50 saves 0 era or somethin like that.

R.a dickey should get it. Would someone like to explain to me how cueto has better numbers than dickey?

Cueto's probably the favorite right now, but I wouldn't be surprised if Dickey won it.

Dickey doesn't have close numbers to cueto? Do your research before you talk.
Cueto: 2.44 ERA, 16-6, 135 K's
dickey: 2.89 ERA, 15-4, 175 K's

Id like to see Burnett finish strong and get some support. Cueto or Dickey as of now, of course these two would have to suck down the stretch also.

[QUOTE=ChaseSeiberlich;3166707]Dickey doesn't have close numbers to cueto? Do your research before you talk.
Cueto: 2.44 ERA, 16-6, 135 K's
dickey: 2.89 ERA, 15-4, 175 K's[/QUOTE]

Who said Dickey's numbers aren't close to Cueto's ? How about understand what you read before you post ?

[QUOTE=cruiserdaddy7;3166558]As i made a thread before on this it will be:
Johnny Cueto or Aroldis Chapman. People thinking Dickey are waaayyyy off. Numbers arent close to Cueto[/QUOTE]

This guy. Please be smart before trying to be smart

I would also like to see Cueto win the NL CY award.

[QUOTE=cruiserdaddy7;3166582]Should be Cuetos. [B]Has better numbers[/B] and leading his team into playoffs. Aroldis Chapman is most dominant pitcher we have seen in years.[/QUOTE]

It's close, I think their numbers are equal. Equal records, innings, games, walks. Cueto has a better ERA, HRs. Dickey has better hits, whip, baa, and strikeouts.

[QUOTE=seancoyle;3166690]R.a dickey should get it. Would someone like to explain to me how cueto has better numbers than dickey?[/QUOTE]

Cueto.. Better ERA, More Wins, better WAR...

Cueto is in a Pennant chase and winning games. Who knows this guy could be an MVP depending on the rest of the season. You just never know

[QUOTE=ChaseSeiberlich;3166734]This guy. Please be smart before trying to be smart[/QUOTE]

Ya got me there, didn't see that post.:o Next time quote the guy ya j*rkoff;)

Not a bad article:
[url=http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1302572-2012-nl-cy-young-belongs-to-the-cincinnati-reds-but-who-will-win-it]2012 NL Cy Young Belongs to the Cincinnati Reds, but Who Will Win It? | Bleacher Report[/url]

As a Reds fan Im a tad biased. Dickey has had an amazing season dont get me wrong. We saw with his last start maybe his stats wouldnt be close to Cuetos pitching in GABP?

I'd rather see Dickey win it

It's going to be close. I'd say it'll either be Cueto or Dickey, but Strasburg / Gio could challenge (maybe not Stas if he gets shut down).

And please, no one (else) make the unbelievably stupid argument about "leading his team to the playoffs."

[QUOTE=BAMBAM;3166769]Ya got me there, didn't see that post.:o Next time quote the guy ya j*rkoff;)[/QUOTE]

Haha sorry, just trying to make my point