Need Help on Possible Trade

[joe31]

Hey guys, its been a while, but I could use some help on a trade. I was fortunate enough to pick up Matt Ryan and Peyton Manning on my fantasy team. Someone recently sent me an offer for Peyton Manning. After immediately thinking no way, the more I think about it I don't need two good qbs on my team, or do I? So heres the options...

Trade P.Manning
Trade Matt Ryan
Keep both...

Also, the guy said he is looking to get rid of Chris Johnson. Is he worth picking up for fairly cheap? Or should I stay away?

Any thoughts would be appreciated.

[mikeman7322]

What is the exact trade? Also who is your 3rd Qb (or who will become your backup)? Nobody can tell you to do this trade unless these two things are told. I prefer matt ryan over manning atm.

[joe31]

Originally Posted by mikeman7322

What is the exact trade? Also who is your 3rd Qb (or who will become your backup)? Nobody can tell you to do this trade unless these two things are told. I prefer matt ryan over manning atm.

I don't really need help deciding who to get for them, just what one to trade or if even to trade one. My backup if I traded one would be Vick(Who Id get in the trade cheap).

[joe31]

But heres the trade anyway:
I trade
Manning
Doug Martin
Jacob Tamme

I get
Vick
Chris Johnson
Jimmy Graham

My other Rbs are Ray Rice and McFadden. TE is probably my weakest position, so getting graham would be huge. I just don't know if I want to trade Manning. I just have a feeling that Matty Ice will start regressing and Manning will start getting back into the groove. You guys agree? Or am I thinking too much?

[mikeman7322]

What you would get has tremendous upside. Vick was ranked higher than manning in a lot of mocks before the season. I truly believe anyone who gets rid of CJ this early will severely regret it. And I love Jimmy Graham. Love him.

If it were me, I would take it.

[spud1972]

Originally Posted by mikeman7322

What you would get has tremendous upside. Vick was ranked higher than manning in a lot of mocks before the season. I truly believe anyone who gets rid of CJ this early will severely regret it. And I love Jimmy Graham. Love him.

If it were me, I would take it.

I totally agree. Take the deal! Ryan is the QB I'd want over Manning, Graham is a must start every week, Tamme is frustrating on my team this year.

[ballahollic2]

why don't i play in leagues where people offer trades like that...jeez

[joe31]

Doug Martin is doing pretty well for tampa. Manning is solid. Tamme I could care less about in this deal. I do actually have Aaron Hernandez, but he's out for a while. Do you guys really think I can trust Ryan for the rest of the year and Vick will bounce back?