Wow... Respect for Eli

[bdubs3316]

Originally Posted by RedSoxFan28

Oh mighty one let's hear you tiers then? How are they way off? The first Tier is pretty solid in Brady, Brees, Peyton, and Rodgers.

Thank you for the reverence, but you really didnt have to

Tier 1
Brady, Rodgers, Peyton, Brees, Eli, Rapistberger

Tier 2
Ryan, Rivers, Stafford, Romo...maybe Flacco & Cutler (others could find their way here soon, but wont give rookies this status, this soon)

Tier 3
Palmer, Dalton, Freeman, Smith and a few others

you can agree or disagree, it doesnt matter to me...it's how I see it. As I stated, you can have your opinion too...it's your right.

[RedSoxFan28]

Originally Posted by RedSoxFan28

The top tier consists of Brady, Brees, and Rodgers.
2nd Tier: Eli is in late 2nd Peyton(Maybe 1st), Stafford, Ryan, Schaub, etc.

Originally Posted by RedSoxFan28

Oh mighty one let's hear you tiers then? How are they way off? The first Tier is pretty solid in Brady, Brees, Peyton, and Rodgers.

Originally Posted by bdubs3316

Thank you for the reverence, but you really didnt have to

Tier 1
Brady, Rodgers, Peyton, Brees, Eli, Rapistberger

Tier 2
Ryan, Rivers, Stafford, Romo...maybe Flacco & Cutler (others could find their way here soon, but wont give rookies this status, this soon)

Tier 3
Palmer, Dalton, Freeman, Smith and a few others

you can agree or disagree, it doesnt matter to me...it's how I see it. As I stated, you can have your opinion too...it's your right.

I didn't real in depth with my Tiers, but ours aren't far off. The only difference is where Eli is. You said mine was completely wrong.

I just don't feel like Eli has been consistent enough to be compared with Brady, Brees, Peyton, and Rodgers. Yes Eli has shown plays/ moments of possible "Elite Status" but has he completely shown to be Elite or in the top tier. I just don's see it yet, he might eventually, but at this moment I don't think he has made it yet.

[enyouartist]

I am the current owner of the 2012 Topps Finest Superfractor Eli Manning. Please pm me with any offers.

[mmkyszka]

Originally Posted by enyouartist

I am the current owner of the 2012 Topps Finest Superfractor Eli Manning. Please pm me with any offers.

I highly doubt it will get more than what you paid for it. That is if you are the one who won the auction