Baseball's 50 Greatest- Auto/signed Framed Display! Gai

[pat_blowoutcards]

BASEBALL'S 50 GREATEST- AUTO/SIGNED FRAMED DISPLAY! GAI - eBay (item 350019698544 end time Feb-26-08 16:59:29 PST)

[thebear29]

Not a closer in the whole list, they get no respect. Otherwise nice piece, I might have chosen a different format for framing.

[GarkoCollector]

theres a few names on there that probably could have had better replacements.

[guru]

This is a great discussion starter... Who would you replace in this and with whom would you replace them???

[guru]

The original 5 Hall of Famers are obvious, but who else?

[CaptainBOHICA]

Each of the world series MVPs

Top 50 sluggers all time

season MVPs from the last 50 years

take your pick

[BAMBAM]

Can't use the original 5 HOFers. The piece is from the years 1950 - 2000 so its has to be players from only those 5 decades. Guy did a nice job but Kirby Puckett being left off for Lou Brock or Dave Winfield is a head scratcher. Don't get me wrong, I think Brock and Winfield were both great players but Kirby Puckett was a better player who won more on lesser teams.

[guru]

My bad on the first HOFers. I missed that... One player that isn't on there is Bonds.

[iluvfish2]

He put blurb on his description about Bonds, McGuire and Sosa. To much controversy on them.

"There were several players that were excluded from the list:
Barry Bonds - Due to the controversy concerning steroids
Mark McGwire - Due to the controversy concerning steroids
Sammy Sosa - Due to the controversy concerning steroids"

[Poonchka]

Originally Posted by BAMBAM

I think Brock and Winfield were both great players but Kirby Puckett was a better player who won more on lesser teams.

Darn Skippy