Favre vs NE or Mcnabb vs Big D

[DadofTwins]

Leaning towards Mcnabb against the Cowboys. Ne D still pretty good....

waiting to see Favre get comfortable... but I think I got a steal late in Mcnabb

[KaraandMelliesDaddy]

I'd take McNabb vs. Dallas, I think they are overrated and the birds appear to be on a mission this year.

[petrucci19]

i disagree i would take favre because he still has alot to prove and he will sling it all over the field. NE D is old. I think Dallas has a great D alot of talent in the DB's

[BAMBAM]

Someone tell me why people were gushing about that GARBAGE pass that Stuckey pulled out of the air to save Favre's rear last week ? I like Favre BUT please give me a break as that play was more rookie mistake then HOF calibur QB. He just got very lucky. NE will pressure him into mistakes and a healthy McNabb will expose Roy Williams' complete lack of coverage skills once again. Not saying the Eagles win but McNabb is a better option then Favre just about every week this year. I still think Favre won't last the year healthy.

[Chops]

This is coming from a Cowboys fan who sadly lives in eagle territory. Start Mcnabb, especially if Terence Newman doesn't play. Unfortunately Mcnabb has had some of his best games in Dallas. Pacman looked like a guy who had a year off against cleveland. Cowboys got lucky with a few edwards dropped passes last week. Don't get me started about Roy Williams coverage skills.

I still think Dallas will win, but the eagles will score some points.

Favre had a pretty good game against a lousy miami defense. New England is a much tougher test.

[DadofTwins]

OK- Here's a good one......

Mcnabb vs Dallas or Romo VS Philly--- these are the 2 Qb's I have in my Espn.com League

[iluvfish2]

Not knowing everything about the Eagles D, I'd say start McNabb as I think they'll be passing closer to the 60% mark in the games. We know Dallas can run in they need to. Romo will probably give you more consistent numbers week to week, but I think his weekly numbers will be lower. Both stand to get extra points if the reciever can get someone to miss or someone gets behind the D.

[flobert1205]

Originally Posted by BAMBAM

Someone tell me why people were gushing about that GARBAGE pass that Stuckey pulled out of the air to save Favre's rear last week ? I like Favre BUT please give me a break as that play was more rookie mistake then HOF calibur QB. He just got very lucky. NE will pressure him into mistakes and a healthy McNabb will expose Roy Williams' complete lack of coverage skills once again. Not saying the Eagles win but McNabb is a better option then Favre just about every week this year. I still think Favre won't last the year healthy.

Totally agree with the heathly point. Just wait until the Bills D is done with him! NE's D might be old, but they are smart. I would take McNabb this week.